Initial Thoughts on the New Food Pyramid
Tags:
The US Department of Agriculture has finally revised their pyramid from the outdated (lots and lots of refined carbs) previous version.
First, let me praise the positive changes:
- it's great to see that they included exercise as being hand-in-hand with diet; it's something I need to work on, and my biggest problem in terms of overall physical wellness
- the purple "meat and beans" slice is small and recommends lean meats, fish, beans and legumes; it's amazing that a goverment agency that is heavily influenced by the cattle industry was able to do this
- the differentiation between whole grains and refined ones is more important than simple vs. complex (e.g. white pasta, rice, bread)
Now the bad:
- it's too damn complicated; not only is the diagram confusing, it's customizeable
- potatoes are not a vegetable; they are nutritionally more akin to grains (unlike other "root vegetables" like, say, carrots, garlic and radishes)
- you don't need dairy every day; it's much healthier to get your calcium and protein from vegetables
- beans are mentioned twice — under vegetables and under meat and beans — I try to eat them often, but what a weird typo
- the yellow "fats" slice is too tiny; a sizeable amount of unsaturated fats (e.g. olives, seeds, nuts and their oils) is a part of heart-healthy diet
It's definitely a step in the right direction, though, for people smart enough to understand it.
update They should have just adopted the Healthy Eating Pyramid.
well, sadly, people smart enough to understand it aren't the ones who desperately need guidance on their diet. I know how I should eat, regardless of whether I actually follow my knowledge! Unfortunately, kids in school are going to be confused by this, which makes it potentially worse than the previous one, I think. As for dairy--things like yogurt contain a lot of active cultures (in decent brands) that are extremely healthy for your digestive tract. Dairy is more than protein+calcium.
Posted by: petrilli on April 19, 2005 3:39 PM | permalinkI bet the bean thing is for vegetarians, who need to eat just that many more beans if they aren't eating meat.
Posted by: Ian Bicking on April 19, 2005 4:01 PM | permalinkThree cups of milk a day is an awful lot of a food that humans never consumed until recent times.
Posted by: O'dell on April 20, 2005 9:01 PM | permalinkIan:
Or, beans and legumes have a higher amount of protein than fruits and vegetables and are thusly placed into the group they happen to call "proteins."
Posted by: O'dell on April 20, 2005 9:03 PM | permalinkNo more comments! Either someone has violated Godwin's Law, I'm tired of the discussion or, most likely, the ten-week window has closed. You can, however, contact me through email.